A well-crafted performance improvement plan (PIP) can be a game-changer for employers and employees. By identifying areas of improvement for employees and setting clear, actionable goals, a PIP helps workers refocus and improve performance. Simultaneously, it encourages talent retention and productivity across an organization.
In this guide, we’ll reveal the essential steps for designing and implementing a PIP that fosters collaboration, clarity, and measurable progress.
What is a PIP?
A performance improvement plan is a structured document designed to address an employee’s specific performance gaps and encourage measurable improvement in their roles. A PIP is typically implemented when a worker struggles to meet role expectations or demonstrates behavior-related concerns. It’s a roadmap to success that includes well-defined goals, actionable steps, and a timeline for achieving progress, ensuring accountability on both sides.
A workplace PIP is a proactive approach to fostering professional growth and empowering valuable team members. Instead of jumping to termination, demotion, or disciplinary action, companies can use PIPs to guide employees toward realignment with organizational standards.
When is it a good idea to implement a PIP?
PIPs can carry a negative connotation, leaving employees feeling anxious or defensive. However, a thoughtfully implemented PIP is a constructive tool for development—not a punitive measure.
A performance improvement plan is most effective when it is introduced at an appropriate time. Here are four scenarios that may call for a PIP:
- After routine performance management has been exhausted: If regular feedback sessions, goal-setting, and performance reviews don’t result in better employee performance, a PIP may be the best next step. It formalizes expectations and provides a clear action plan for growth that aligns both parties.
- After considering personal challenges: Before initiating a PIP, evaluate whether personal or health-related issues contribute to performance gaps. If such factors exist, support or adjustments may be more effective than a formal plan.
- When the environment and resources have been optimized: Only introduce a PIP after confirming that the employee has been trained effectively and given the tools to succeed. For example, if an employee is receiving unclear goals or insufficient resources, those issues should be addressed first.
- After consulting with Human Resources (HR) or third-party perspectives: In some cases, performance challenges stem from misaligned expectations or interpersonal dynamics rather than inadequate abilities. Input from HR can clarify whether an issue warrants a PIP and ensure that the process is unbiased and constructive.
Benefits of a performance improvement plan (PIP)
A well-executed PIP offers advantages beyond addressing immediate performance challenges. Here are four significant benefits:
1. Enhanced employee experience
Employees thrive when they feel supported in their growth. A carefully crafted PIP provides thoughtful goals and actionable feedback, helping employees feel understood, valued, and engaged. This structure can boost morale and foster a greater sense of purpose in one’s work.
2. Closing skill gaps
Skill deficiencies are often at the core of job performance issues. By identifying gaps and implementing targeted training or support, a PIP resolves immediate challenges and equips employees with the tools to succeed in their roles long-term.
3. Strengthened relationships
A PIP opens the door for transparent, constructive conversations between team members and supervisors. These discussions build trust and mutual understanding, creating a more collaborative and supportive workplace dynamic.
4. Increased employee retention
A PIP demonstrates a commitment to employee development, signaling that an organization values its people. It helps underperforming employees get back on track and reduces turnover by reinforcing a culture of growth. A well-executed PIP can be a positive force in the workplace.
How to write a performance improvement plan in 8 steps
Designing and implementing a PIP requires extensive planning and clear communication. Follow these steps to develop effective improvement plans:
1. Evaluate whether a PIP is the correct approach
Before drafting a PIP, confirm that it’s suitable for the situation. Assess whether the performance gaps are addressable and whether the employee is willing to improve. If the concerns stem from personal challenges or inadequate support, address these issues first.
2. Gather detailed performance data
Collect all relevant information about the employee’s performance, including measurable metrics, documented feedback, and examples of missed goals or behavior concerns. Measurable metrics may include sales targets, error rates, time management, absenteeism, and punctuality. This data substantiates the need for a PIP and guarantees that it’s based on objective evidence.
3. Collaborate with the employee’s manager
Work closely with the employee’s manager to identify the root causes of performance issues and ensure that the PIP presents relevant goals and expectations. Supervisors should be committed to supporting their team members throughout the process.
4. Draft a structured plan
Research performance improvement plan examples and templates to guide you as you create the PIP. Outline specific areas of concern for the employee, set measurable performance goals, and establish a timeline for improvement. Include an action plan with elements like training sessions or mentorship opportunities to help the team member succeed.
5. Verify compliance and alignment
Review the PIP to confirm that it aligns with company policies and legal requirements. Legal requirements may stem from employment contracts, nondiscrimination laws, or local labor laws. In addition, goals outlined in the PIP should be realistic, unbiased, and achievable within the given timeline.
6. Present the plan to the employee
Schedule a meeting with the team member to discuss the PIP. Clearly explain your concerns and expectations while emphasizing the company’s commitment to the worker’s success. Invite the employee to provide feedback and ask questions.
7. Monitor progress through regular check-ins
Schedule periodic meetings to review progress, provide additional guidance, and adjust the plan as needed. These check-ins keep the process on track and demonstrate ongoing support from the manager and the company.
8. Conclude the PIP and review its outcomes
At the end of the PIP timeline, meet with the employee to review their progress. If the worker achieved their assigned goals, celebrate their success and outline follow-up steps to maintain their work performance. If they didn’t meet expectations, discuss alternative actions (e.g., extending the PIP or terminating their employment).
Tips to implement a PIP successfully
Maximize the impact of a PIP and create a supportive path to success with these four additional tips:
Engage the employee when developing the PIP
Collaboration guarantees the performance improvement plan feels fair and achievable while securing employee buy-in. Involve the worker by requesting input on challenges they’re facing and potential solutions. You’ll ensure that the PIP addresses root concerns and remains tailored to the individual team member.
Provide consistent, constructive feedback
Feedback shouldn’t end after delivering the PIP. Schedule regular check-ins to evaluate progress, celebrate wins, and address obstacles. Constructive feedback keeps the employee motivated and provides opportunities to adjust strategies, reinforcing that the company is invested in their growth.
Keep detailed records of the employee’s progress
Documenting the PIP process is essential—not just for tracking work performance but also for ensuring fairness and transparency. Record all actions, feedback, and milestones, creating a clear history of the employee’s efforts and the company’s support. These records also protect the organization in case of a dispute.
Acknowledge and celebrate improvements
Recognizing progress, no matter how small, can significantly boost an employee’s morale and motivation. A simple acknowledgment during PIP check-ins or a formal note of appreciation reinforces their efforts. Positive feedback can inspire continued improvements and help the team member feel valued.
Tackle employee challenges worldwide with Oyster’s expert support
When you effectively manage employee performance, you foster a thriving workplace. An essential part of employee management is supporting struggling employees with well-structured PIPs. SMART goals, actionable strategies, and collaborative execution ensure your PIPs turn challenges into opportunities for growth.
Tackling employee challenges worldwide? Trust Oyster to guide you through complex global employment scenarios with tailored expertise and innovative solutions. We go beyond the basics, helping you examine every aspect of your global talent strategy so it evolves and scales to meet the needs of your business and workforce.
About Oyster
Oyster is a global employment platform designed to enable visionary HR leaders to find, engage, pay, manage, develop, and take care of a thriving distributed workforce. Oyster lets growing companies give valued international team members the experience they deserve, without the usual headaches and expense.
Oyster enables hiring anywhere in the world—with reliable, compliant payroll, and great local benefits and perks.
